Toy Car Insurance Campaign

Writer/Creative Director + Video Director/Producer/Voiceover
Winner: Gold, Silver, Judges Choice Addy Awards; Platinum Viddy Award

The assignment: explain Hagerty’s complicated Guaranteed Value policy and show how much money you could lose with the wrong insurance—with a very short video.

Our solution: Cut a car in half. To help visualize the concept, we ordered some toy cars and went to work with a sledgehammer and a circular saw.

The ad was a big success, and what started as a one-off video turned into an ongoing campaign with programatic, broadcast and social ads, emails, landing pages and more. These ads were created entirely in-house by the team I was leading as creative director, and are a good example of the many hats I wore while in that role: I served as Creative Director, Scriptwriter, Producer, Video Director, and even ended up doing the voiceover when my temp VO track struck the right chord.

Miniature vintage and sports cars on a surface with a disco ball overhead, surrounded by gold confetti, with overlay text 'Ring in the new year with magically good coverage' and Hagerty Insurance logo.

45% Lift

…in Google searches for Hagerty Brand name among viewers of Toy Car spots

A collage with a quote about bad things happening to good cars, featuring images of three different cars and a quote from Hagerty.
Miniature models of a Volkswagen van, a bowling ball on a wooden stand, and a small sign reading 'World's Largest Bowling Ball' on a table with a blurred background.
Advertisement with two side-by-side images of cars and text about vehicle insurance. The left side shows a toy car under falling rain with a wooden plank and bricks on top, with the caption 'Bad things happen to good cars.' The right side displays a clean toy car with the text 'We make it right.'
Yellow sports car with blue car jack lifting the front end, dark background, text reading 'WE GET YOUR CAR FIXED,' Hagerty insurance logo, and a blue 'Quote now' button.
A red toy sports car on a black surface with a background of wood logs, with overlay text: 'Pretend this is your collector car' and a blue button labeled 'Quote now' for HAGERTY insurance.
A white SUV parked on a plain dark background with the days of the week, 'Monday' displayed at the top.
Comparison between two toy cars with text: 'Bad things happen to good cars' over a dripping blue liquid on the car on the left, and 'Hagerty makes it right' with a clean, shiny car on the right.

15% increase

...in insurance quotes YOY generated by Toy Car campaign

Other Insurance Ads

A man sitting on a motorcycle at a bike shop with motorcycles in the background. Text overlay says 'There’s not an app for this' and 'Hagerty for people who love bikes' with a blue button that says 'Ride with us'.
A man driving a red 1967 Porsche 911S along a forested road, with the vehicle in motion and trees blurred in the background.
A silver sports car driving on a track with a grassy background. Text reads: 'Life happens on track day. Everything else is just practice.' Hagerty logo and a 'Learn more' button.
Four people enjoying time on a boat on a lake. One person is in the water holding a frisbee, and the others are on the boat. The boat is floating on water with a cloudy sky above. Text on the image says "NO WIFI NO PROBLEM" and promotes boat insurance from Hagerty.
Two cars racing on a track, with a caption promoting a Honda dealership and a call-to-action button to drive with them.
A classic silver vintage car driving on an open road with clear skies and mountains in the background, accompanied by promotional text for Hagerty insurance.